With home prices down 10 – 25% in Southern California, we are increasingly encountering clients who don’t know what to do when they need to sell or refinance in today’s troubled real estate and mortgage markets.
Of course, if you’ve got enough equity in your home, selling or refinancing is not such a problem, although you’ll net less cash out than you would have a year or two ago. We’ve got lots of ways to help sellers maximize their net in today’s market, but that will have to wait for another post. (If you can’t wait, call us at 562 822 7653 or post a question in the comments below & we’ll give a brief summary)
The real crunch comes when you owe more than 90% of what your home’s worth. For refinancing, that’s because 100% refinance loans have largely disappeared.
For sellers, it’s because the total cost of selling a home today generally runs between 8 – 12% of the sales price (escrow, commission, termite, title, home warranty, & often points and incentives).
As we see it, homeowners with little, no, or negative equity have at least 7 options:
1. Live with your existing loan the way it is. If you can make the payments and plan to live there for a long time, you’ll eventually be fine. Depending on when you bought, what you put down, & when the market recovers, it may take 2 – 10 years, but inflation eventually should bail you out. (For our projections for Southern California housing, check out “A Change in Our Projections?”)
I’ll bet your car, clothes, appliances, and furniture are all worth less today than what you paid for them, and they’re not expected to go up over the next 2 – 10 years, either. However, if your loan is scheduled to adjust up to where the payments or interest rate is unreasonable, option # 2 is worth trying:
2. If you’ve got one of those killer loans that’s already adjusted up or will shortly, try to negotiate with your lender for better terms. It’s never a good idea to just give up without at least trying to work something out. It doesn’t hurt or cost anything to ask. You might ask to have the interest rate reduced or held at the current low level until the home goes up in value enough to allow you to sell or refinance. Lenders are much more willing to negotiate if you have a legitimate hardship, but if you didn’t have a hardship you probably wouldn’t have a problem making the payments.
Bad loans had a lot to do with the current real estate mess (see “How We Got Into This Mess“). If your loan was misrepresented by your lender, you might mention it in a matter-of-fact, non accusatory way.
3. You could also try to negotiate for a reduced principle balance to allow you to refinance or to at least make the payments on the current loan. This is sometimes known as a “cram down.” If there’s no equity, they really don’t want your home back, & they could lose a lot more if they had to foreclose. As an added incentive, you might propose some sort of equity sharing arrangement as partial compensation, although I wouldn’t start off with that, & I’d try to keep it modest.
4. Negotiate a “short sale” with your lender. The lender reduces the payoff amount to allow you to close escrow with little or no out of pocket expense. Most lenders prefer this to a foreclosure, but they can be tough and sometimes unreasonable. Still, we’ve been able to negotiate payoff discounts well over $100,000 for a number of our sellers over the last year, just as we did during the 1991 – 1996 downturn. In fact, lenders seem to be more reasonable and more eager to deal this time around. If you’re going this route, you need an excellent, experienced negotiator on your side; the bank’s got plenty of them on theirs. Most real estate agents will tell you they can do that, but if they don’t have at least 15 years experience, I’d avoid them.
In fact, before talking to any agents, check out our post on “Top 5 Ways NOT to Pick an Agent.” You might also want to take a look at our experience & advice on “How to Sell Your So Cal Home for Top Dollar in 30 Days.”
5. Bring cash to escrow to enable a sale or refinance. During the last recession, we saw many sellers write checks to escrow for thousands of dollars to enable them to sell. This keeps their credit & their conscience clean, while allowing them to move on. For those with significant assets, it’s worth considering.
6. “Give the home back to the bank.” This is generally referred to as a “deed in lieu” of foreclosure, and it still saves the bank time and money over foreclosing. However, if there are other encumbrances (2nd T.D., equity line, judgements, tax liens, etc.) they may prefer to foreclose, to wipe out those junior liens.
7. Let the lender foreclose. In California, that give you a minimum of about 120 days you can live in the house without making payments from when the lender files their Notice of Default (you’ll get a copy!). That “N.o.D.” usually isn’t filed until you’ve missed at least two payments, sometimes a lot more.
Here’s some possible steps to figure out which option might work best for you:
1. Pray, if you’re so inclined. In this case, it wouldn’t be a bad idea even if you’re not so inclined! We could all use some divine wisdom & intervention to get through the current mortgage mess! Like I said above, it never hurts to ask!
2. Get the facts on your loan. Review your last statement to find out exactly what you owe. Check your loan documents or call customer “service” to find out when your payment will adjust & by how much. (If you call, & you’ve got a big bump coming, you might want to try this when they tell you: Inhale sharply, then say “Oh no! I don’t know how we can handle that!” Then shut up & wait to see if they offer anything. Silence is one of the most powerful of negotiating tools, & whoever speaks first to break the silence usually loses.)
3. Get the facts on what your home’s worth. I suggest calling an experienced, honest, full time, diligent Realtor. We’d be happy to refer one, or possibly even help you out ourselves. 562 822 SOLD. Or e-mail RealtorDaveE at msn dot com. (Use the symbol @ for “at” and a period for “dot–” we have to be careful to avoid spamming web crawlers, sorry.) The agent can also give you a more accurate idea of your costs of sale and what preparation & staging would be best. We don’t recommend selling by owner or using a part-time or inexperienced agent in today’s market.
4. Consider the tax, credit, & ethical consequences of the various options. Tax wise, the recently passed federal Mortgage Forgiveness Debt Relief Act of 2007 can save thousands in tax for most borrowers exercising options 3, 4, 6, or 7 above in 2007, 2008, or 2009. Don’t ignore the ethical implications–I can’t think of anyone who’s ever regretted doing the right thing, but lots of people who’ve regretted unethical behavior. Credit wise, options 1 & 5 shouldn’t hurt your credit at all, neither should option 2 in most cases. Options 3 & 4 are generally considered less harmful than 6 or 7, especially if you continue making payments, but you’ll want to ask your lender if & how it will be reported to the credit bureaus.
Obviously, this post is general in nature & you should consult the appropriate legal, tax, real estate and other professionals for your specific situation & state. Our point is, you do have options, and doing nothing is generally considered the worst option of all. Good luck, & let us know how things work out!
As always, your thoughts & comments are welcome.